Encod.org
Europe


GOLD MEMBERS


RED MEMBERS


GREEN MEMBERS

Patrick Firnkes
Assonabis
Coffeeshop Pink
Asociación Hempower
Percy Grower
Tricomaria.com
DUTSI Cannabis Social Club
FAC
DOUG FINE
COL.CAN.CAN
Bushdoctor
Marco Bruni
Giacomo Oliva
ASOCIACION LLIURE ANTIPROHIBICIONISTA
Bart Behets
The Stoned Society
Ehkeef
Richard Rainsford
Jorge Roque
CASA MARIA
FEDCAC
AIRAM
ASBL SATIVA
LES AMIS DU CSCF
MOUNTAIN HIGH
SIBARITAS MEDCAN
SENSI SEEDS BV
BJÖRN SICKEL
ESTEBAN SÁNCHEZ
NORML FRANCE
SCALVENZI MATTEO
ACMEFUER
LUKAS HURT
MERES POUR LA MARIJUANA
DINAFEM SEEDS
KID DE WINTER
CANNABIS MAGAZINE
ORGANIC EARTH
HPP (ASSOCIATION FOR HUMANE DRUG POLICY)
KREATIV & KULTURVEREIN "LEGAL EUROPE"
CIPRIANO GIL
ASSOCIACIÓ KALI CLUB
LUCIE-TÉRÈSE FAURE
CANNABIS SOCIAL CLUB MARIBOR

MEMBERSHIP / view all

 
Home page > English (en) > 02. News > 2010 > A CHANCE FOR SCIENTIFIC DRUG POLICY
Published on 25 September 2010  by encod

A CHANCE FOR SCIENTIFIC DRUG POLICY

The Guardian (UK)

21 September 2010

David Nutt

There’s a growing recognition that Labour’s incoherent drugs policy has failed. Let’s build a science-based replacement



All the versions of this article: [English]





Last week Professor Roger Pertwee called for cannabis to be licensed for sale, and now Tim Hollis, the Association of Chief Police Officers’ lead officer on drugs, has said the current criminalisation-based approach to policing cannabis use should be reviewed. Pertwee and Hollis are bringing a welcome breath of fresh air to the debate about drugs and the harm they do.

The government now has the chance to take a genuinely science-based approach to drugs policy. Labour took an extremely distorted and punitive view of cannabis. It rejected both scientific evidence and public opinion that its harms were relatively modest and reclassified it to Class B status under the 1971 Misuse of Drugs Act so that possession for personal use can now result in up to five years in prison. Worse, Labour also instigated a policy of pursuing users with an almost religious fervour with police sniffer dogs assisting in interventions at tube stations and other places where users might be easily sequestered and searched.

Why was this done? It appears that Labour believed that cannabis was very harmful to mental health; especially that it caused schizophrenia. Yet as the advisory body the ACMD pointed out in its 2008 cannabis review, to stop one case of schizophrenia more than 5,000 young men would have to be prevented from ever using cannabis. This statistic negates any meaningful value in controlling cannabis to improve mental health.

Labour also held the view that punishment would reduce use and hence harms. There is no meaningful evidence in favour of this view. The evidence we do have – for example, from the experiences with decriminalisation in the Netherlands and some Australian states – is that decriminalisation leads to a reduction in harms.

Science cannot determine alone what the framework for drugs regulation should be. But if policy is not grounded in the science it can easily collapse into prejudice, moralism and authoritarianism. The chaos earlier this year over the "legal high" mephedrone raised very significant issues of evidence in relation to new drugs of unknown harm. Alcohol is legal yet is producing growing levels of damage which are well detailed in government reports but recommendations for harm reduction are not acted upon. A recent scientific review of drug harms, originally published in The Lancet, found that many class A drugs are in fact less harmful than alcohol. This raises further questions over the coherence of current drugs laws.

In the face of a rising tide of dissatisfaction with the intellectual rationale for the current drugs laws, the coalition should seize the opportunity to establish a genuinely science-based approach to drugs policy.





Share |



Reply to this article


The European Coalition for Just and Effective Drug Policies, is a pan-European network of currently 140 NGO’s and individual experts involved in the drug issue on a daily base. We are the European section of an International Coalition, which consists of more than 200 NGOs from around the world that have adhered to a Manifesto for Just and Effective Drug Policies (established in 1998). Among our members are organisations of cannabis and other drug users, of health workers, researchers, grassroot activists as well as companies.


Secretariat: Haantjeslei 213 | 2018 Antwerpen | Belgium | Tel: +32 (0)495 122 644 | E-mail: office@encod.org
© Encod.org 2014 :: Design by: Navetrece.com